I agree. I went with the
Smartliners in part because they were more then 50% off the price of the
Tuxmat's when I bought them last year. Also about 1/2 the price of
WeatherTech which I had in my last car before the Telluride and I like these better.
I got rows 1-3 and they work great and cleaned up nice after winter; better then the WeatherTechs cleaned up. The combination of
Price vs. Performance vs. Looks give the
Smartliners the win for me. If money doesn't matter,
Tuxmat's I'm sure would be great and probably a step up (my guess since I've not used or seen them in person).